- Presentation abstract発表の要約
As the coronavirus pandemic evolves into a permanent, endemic condition for all schools, educators must decide the educational philosophy to guide choices of whether to do classes on-line, in-person, or some version of blended learning. To make that design decision, this short presentation investigates the role of the physical/virtual presence of the teacher, the physical/virtual actions of students, the use of realia, printed and digital materials, and spaces/locations used in education with the Moodle LMS. It is a theoretical introduction to the question of embodiment in education, the diverse modalities of interaction, as well as critiquing the material/human semiotics of the online classroom vs. the face-to-face classroom. I will give some examples of performance-based use of Moodle (i.e. presentations, teacher-training, internships) with classroom activities using face-to-face technologies and asynchronous activities using Moodle plugins for performance learning (Video Assessment Module). Also, I will demonstrate assessments that engage the body as well as the mind (rubrics focusing on non-verbal behavior). This short talk will also introduce practical implications for research in this area, as participants will be invited to be co-researchers on a permanent Moodle whiteboard.
- Original submission元の原稿
発表の題名: Moodle and the Body: Embodiment in Education
発表の種類: Presentation (20 mins) プレゼンテーション(20分)
発表の言語: English 英語
発表のキーワード:
As the coronavirus pandemic evolves into a permanent, endemic condition for all schools, educators must decide the educational philosophy to guide choices of whether to do classes on-line, in-person, or some version of hybrid. This short presentation investigates the role of the physical body, materials, and location in education using Moodle LMS. It is a theoretical introduction to the question of embodiment or presence in education, as well as critiquing the material/human semiotics of the online classroom vs. the face-to-face classroom. I will give some examples of performance-based use of Moodle with classroom activities using face-to-face technologies and asynchronous activities using Moodle plugins for performance learning. Also, I will demonstrate assessments that engage the body as well as the mind. This lightning talk will also introduce practical implications for research in this area, as participants will be invited to be co-researchers on a permanent Moodle whiteboard.
- Peer review details査読詳細
Peer Review 1
Criteria | Assessment |
Clarity of Submission | 8 / 10 |
Presentation Length | 5 / 10 |
Originality of Submission | 7 / 10 |
Appropriateness & Relevance to the Moot | 8 / 10 |
Quality of Content & Writing | 7 / 10 |
Overall evaluation | 40 / 50 |
| 75 / 100 |
Feedback I recommend this proposal. However, please clarify if this will be a 20-minute presentation or a "lightning talk" that is referred to in the last sentence of the abstract. Lightning talks are a different category and are only 10-minutes long.
Peer Review 2
Criteria | Assessment |
Clarity of Submission | 6 / 10 |
Presentation Length | 6 / 10 |
Originality of Submission | 8 / 10 |
Appropriateness & Relevance to the Moot | 6 / 10 |
Quality of Content & Writing | 7 / 10 |
Overall evaluation | 35 / 50 |
| 68 / 100 |
Feedback I am not sure about the format. The abstract mentions a lightning talk whereas this is listed as a 20-minute presentation. In addition, the content seems almost philosophical, and this would require a lengthy introduction of the background literature, which will prove hard if not impossible to do in 20 minutes.
Peer Review 3
Criteria | Assessment |
Clarity of Submission | 5 / 10 |
Presentation Length | 6 / 10 |
Originality of Submission | 8 / 10 |
Appropriateness & Relevance to the Moot | 7 / 10 |
Quality of Content & Writing | 6 / 10 |
Overall evaluation | 35 / 50 |
| 67 / 100 |
Feedback Without specifics this sounds very "airy fairy" I'm afraid. Some more details on what "the question of embodiment or presence in education" is all about, some references as to its importance, and some details on specific examples would be useful. The same could be said of "performance-based use of Moodle". What does that mean? Some examples would be appreciated by prospective participants I'm sure.
- Peer review notes査読メモ
Thanks for your submission!
Your proposal has been conditionally accepted.
- For this submission to be fully accepted, please make the requested changes to your abstract/presentation before 2022 Jan 22 (Sat) 23:55.
- When the changes have been made, they will be reviewed and you will be notified of the new acceptance status.